Donate
Donate
Donate
Map (Main index)
Map (Main index)
Map (Main index)
Home page
Home page
Home page
Spanish language
Spanish language
Spanish language
Search
Search
Search
Latest updates
Latest updates
Latest updates
Mailing list
Mailing list
Mailing list
Subdomains
Subdomains
Subdomains
Blog
Blog
Blog
RSS Feeds
RSS Feeds
RSS Feeds
Statistics
Statistics
Statistics
Follow DXMAPS on Twitter
Follow DXMAPS on Twitter
Follow DXMAPS on Twitter
Follow DXMAPS on Facebook
Follow DXMAPS on Facebook
Follow DXMAPS on Facebook
Subscribe DXMAPS channel in Telegram
Subscribe DXMAPS channel in Telegram
Subscribe DXMAPS channel in Telegram
Terms of service
Terms of service
Terms of service
Privacy policy
Privacy policy
Privacy policy
Cookies
Cookies
Cookies
Contact webmaster
Contact webmaster
Contact webmaster
on 144 Mhz
on 144 Mhz
on 144 Mhz
on 50 Mhz
on 50 Mhz
on 50 Mhz
on HF - CW
on HF - CW
on HF - CW
on HF - SSB
on HF - SSB
on HF - SSB
on 1296 Mhz
on 1296 Mhz
on 1296 Mhz
on 432 Mhz
on 432 Mhz
on 432 Mhz
on 144 Mhz
on 144 Mhz
on 144 Mhz
on 50 Mhz
on 50 Mhz
on 50 Mhz
On-Line logbook search
On-Line logbook search
On-Line logbook search
Request a sked with EA6VQ
Request a sked with EA6VQ
Request a sked with EA6VQ
My activity as a Radio Amateur
My activity as a Radio Amateur
My activity as a Radio Amateur
Summaries
Summaries
Summaries
My shack and antennas
My shack and antennas
My shack and antennas
Multi-op activities
Multi-op activities
Multi-op activities
Portable operations
Portable operations
Portable operations
DXCC entities worked
DXCC entities worked
DXCC entities worked
Locators worked
Locators worked
Locators worked
Initial QSOs via EME
Initial QSOs via EME
Initial QSOs via EME
144 Mhz. sporadic-E statistics
144 Mhz. sporadic-E statistics
144 Mhz. sporadic-E statistics
WSJT MS QSOs
WSJT MS QSOs
WSJT MS QSOs
About EA6VQ
About EA6VQ
About EA6VQ
Contact me
Contact me
Contact me
Follow EA6VQ on Twitter
Follow EA6VQ on Twitter
Follow EA6VQ on Twitter
My activity
My activity
My activity
MyMallorca.blog
MyMallorca.blog
MyMallorca.blog
My photo album
My photo album
My photo album
My travels
My travels
My travels
Hiking
Hiking
Hiking
Weather station
Weather station
Weather station
MS flight simulator
MS flight simulator
MS flight simulator
Humor, jokes, memes..
Humor, jokes, memes..
Humor, jokes, memes..
Propagation
Propagation
Propagation
Cables/Transmission lines
Cables/Transmission lines
Cables/Transmission lines
Power splitters / phasing
Power splitters / phasing
Power splitters / phasing
Antennas / Stacking
Antennas / Stacking
Antennas / Stacking
Amplifiers / Preamplifiers
Amplifiers / Preamplifiers
Amplifiers / Preamplifiers
Rotators
Rotators
Rotators
Operating
Operating
Operating
Measuring
Measuring
Measuring
50 MHz
50 MHz
50 MHz
144 MHz
144 MHz
144 MHz
432 MHz
432 MHz
432 MHz
Easy guide to FT8 Fox/Hound
Easy guide to FT8 Fox/Hound
Easy guide to FT8 Fox/Hound
DX calendar database
DX calendar database
DX calendar database
VHF & up DX calendar
VHF & up DX calendar
VHF & up DX calendar
DUBUS articles
DUBUS articles
DUBUS articles
Moon bounce (EME)
Moon bounce (EME)
Moon bounce (EME)
VE7BQH's antenna gain chart
VE7BQH's antenna gain chart
VE7BQH's antenna gain chart
EA6VQ's EME calendar
EA6VQ's EME calendar
EA6VQ's EME calendar
About EME reports and QSL cards
About EME reports and QSL cards
About EME reports and QSL cards
TEP on 144 Mhz
TEP on 144 Mhz
TEP on 144 Mhz
Ham radio related sounds
Ham radio related sounds
Ham radio related sounds
6 el. Yagi DJ9BV for 6 meters
6 el. Yagi DJ9BV for 6 meters
6 el. Yagi DJ9BV for 6 meters
Where to find MGF-1302
Where to find MGF-1302
Where to find MGF-1302
Moon phase on-line
Moon phase on-line
Moon phase on-line
Setup
Setup
Setup
Configuration
Configuration
Configuration
Interface PC-Radio
Interface PC-Radio
Interface PC-Radio
Introduction to JT65B EME
Introduction to JT65B EME
Introduction to JT65B EME
Example of a JT65B QSO
Example of a JT65B QSO
Example of a JT65B QSO
...another example
...another example
...another example
Europe
Europe
Europe
America
America
America
VK/JA
VK/JA
VK/JA
Real-time sporadic-E clouds & MUF
Real-time sporadic-E clouds & MUF
Real-time sporadic-E clouds & MUF
Real-time VHF & up QSO
Real-time VHF & up QSO
Real-time VHF & up QSO
Real-time LF - HF QSO
Real-time LF - HF QSO
Real-time LF - HF QSO
On-Line database of VHF & up QSO
On-Line database of VHF & up QSO
On-Line database of VHF & up QSO
Summaries 144 MHz in Europe
Summaries 144 MHz in Europe
Summaries 144 MHz in Europe
Sporadic-E clouds
Sporadic-E clouds
Sporadic-E clouds
Calulate locator,etc. on a map
Calulate locator,etc. on a map
Calulate locator,etc. on a map
Map of locators of Mallorca (JM19)
Map of locators of Mallorca (JM19)
Map of locators of Mallorca (JM19)
TEP on 144 Mhz
TEP on 144 Mhz
TEP on 144 Mhz
Long tropospheric paths
Long tropospheric paths
Long tropospheric paths
Moon bounce (EME)
Moon bounce (EME)
Moon bounce (EME)
My favorites
My favorites
My favorites
Ham radio in Spain
Ham radio in Spain
Ham radio in Spain
Six meter DX information
Six meter DX information
Six meter DX information
Real-time sporadic-E clouds & MUF
Real-time sporadic-E clouds & MUF
Real-time sporadic-E clouds & MUF
Alerts by E-Mail
Alerts by E-Mail
Alerts by E-Mail
Propagation modes on VHF & up
Propagation modes on VHF & up
Propagation modes on VHF & up
Summaries 144 MHz in Europe
Summaries 144 MHz in Europe
Summaries 144 MHz in Europe
Sporadic-E maps
Sporadic-E maps
Sporadic-E maps
Real-time VHF & up QSO
Real-time VHF & up QSO
Real-time VHF & up QSO
Real-time LF-HF QSO
Real-time LF-HF QSO
Real-time LF-HF QSO
VOACAP point to point calculator
VOACAP point to point calculator
VOACAP point to point calculator
TEP on 144 Mhz
TEP on 144 Mhz
TEP on 144 Mhz
The ionosphere at VHF
The ionosphere at VHF
The ionosphere at VHF
Long delayed echos
Long delayed echos
Long delayed echos
Indexes - Historical database
Indexes - Historical database
Indexes - Historical database
144 Mhz. sporadic-E statistics
144 Mhz. sporadic-E statistics
144 Mhz. sporadic-E statistics
Reflexion on the coast
Reflexion on the coast
Reflexion on the coast
Long tropospheric paths
Long tropospheric paths
Long tropospheric paths
From EA on VHF-UHF
From EA on VHF-UHF
From EA on VHF-UHF
From EA6 on VHF-UHF
From EA6 on VHF-UHF
From EA6 on VHF-UHF
From EA8 on VHF-UHF
From EA8 on VHF-UHF
From EA8 on VHF-UHF
From EA9 on VHF-UHF
From EA9 on VHF-UHF
From EA9 on VHF-UHF
From EA via satellite
From EA via satellite
From EA via satellite
From EA6 via satellite
From EA6 via satellite
From EA6 via satellite
From EA8 via satellite
From EA8 via satellite
From EA8 via satellite
From EA9 via satellite
From EA9 via satellite
From EA9 via satellite
Index
Index
Index
Radio Sherlock search engine
Radio Sherlock search engine
Radio Sherlock search engine
Discussions
Discussions
Discussions
Infos
Infos
Infos
WSJT (JT65B,FSK441)
WSJT (JT65B,FSK441)
WSJT (JT65B,FSK441)
Maps
Maps
Maps
Links
Links
Links
Propagation
Propagation
Propagation
First-ever QSO
First-ever QSO
First-ever QSO
DXCC standings
DXCC standings
DXCC standings
General info
General info
General info
Download
Download
Download
FAQ
FAQ
FAQ
Mailing list
Mailing list
Mailing list
General info & download
General info & download
General info & download
FAQ
FAQ
FAQ
Mailing list
Mailing list
Mailing list
Index
Index
Index
VQLog - Ham logbook
VQLog - Ham logbook
VQLog - Ham logbook
Put your log online
Put your log online
Put your log online
The DXCC spreadsheet
The DXCC spreadsheet
The DXCC spreadsheet
Callsign & Locator database
Callsign & Locator database
Callsign & Locator database
Online EME calculator
Online EME calculator
Online EME calculator
Show locator on a map
Show locator on a map
Show locator on a map
Callsign Tracking & Statistics
Callsign Tracking & Statistics
Callsign Tracking & Statistics
VOACAP point to point calculator
VOACAP point to point calculator
VOACAP point to point calculator
Ham radio cliparts
Ham radio cliparts
Ham radio cliparts
AIS DX Aggregator
AIS DX Aggregator
AIS DX Aggregator
APRS DX Aggregator
APRS DX Aggregator
APRS DX Aggregator
WSJT DX Aggregator
WSJT DX Aggregator
WSJT DX Aggregator
MAP65 DX Aggregator
MAP65 DX Aggregator
MAP65 DX Aggregator
ON4KST chat telnet client
ON4KST chat telnet client
ON4KST chat telnet client
VQSpot for VQLog
VQSpot for VQLog
VQSpot for VQLog
SatWarn for SatPC32
SatWarn for SatPC32
SatWarn for SatPC32
Real-time sporadic-E clouds & MUF
Real-time sporadic-E clouds & MUF
Real-time sporadic-E clouds & MUF
Propagation alerts by E-Mail
Propagation alerts by E-Mail
Propagation alerts by E-Mail
Real-time QSO maps
Real-time QSO maps
Real-time QSO maps
Real-time QSO lists
Real-time QSO lists
Real-time QSO lists
Real-time VHF&up propagation ticker
Real-time VHF&up propagation ticker
Real-time VHF&up propagation ticker
QSO database
QSO database
QSO database
Send formated DX spots
Send formated DX spots
Send formated DX spots
Callsign & Locator database
Callsign & Locator database
Callsign & Locator database
DX Atlas
DX Atlas
DX Atlas
DX calendar
DX calendar
DX calendar
DX Callsign Tracking & Statistics
DX Callsign Tracking & Statistics
DX Callsign Tracking & Statistics
DX Cluster
DX Cluster
DX Cluster
User manual
User manual
User manual
Latest news
Latest news
Latest news
Currently active
Currently active
Currently active
7 day calendar
7 day calendar
7 day calendar
30 day calendar
30 day calendar
30 day calendar
Future calendar
Future calendar
Future calendar
News ticker
News ticker
News ticker
Radio Sherlock
Radio Sherlock
Radio Sherlock
Search this site
Search this site
Search this site
German
German
German
French
French
French
Portuguese
Portuguese
Portuguese
Russian
Russian
Russian
Login
Login
Login
Register
Register
Register
Site
Site
Site
Personal
Personal
Personal
Radio
Radio
Radio
Software
Software
Software
DX maps
DX maps
DX maps
DX news
DX news
DX news
Translate
Translate
Translate
Login
Login
Login

Maximum allowable error when cutting
the phasing lines

The following discussion about the maximum allowable error when cutting the phasing lines place in the Moon-Net reflector. I found the subject so interesting that I decided to put together all the messages in this page.

On 7-May-2001 G0RUZ wrote:
I am just about to trim some phasing lines for 144 and 432 Mhz. I have a vector voltmeter and a signal generator and a 50 ohm hybrid so I can measure phase with good accuracy. I was wondering what is considered an acceptable phase error on phasing lines. I have been told that anything less than 4 degrees is OK. This equates to 23mm on 144 and 7.7 mm on 432.

This is quite easy to achieve mechanically and in fact my early measurements indicate that I have achieved a 1 degree error on 144 without even trimming! I managed this by using a piece of tubing the same length as the line needs to be cut. I put a connector on one end which could not pass through the tube and then pulled the cable through the tube and kept the tension on the cable high while I sawed it flush with the end of the piece of tubing. I then measured the phase error between the first cable cut and the seven subsequent cables and all were around 1 degree or so. I was slightly surprised by this and so cut another about 20mm long. This showed a error of + 4.2 degrees which is pretty good when the velocity factor of the FSJ4 is taken into account.

The 70cms cables will be another matter entirely of course.

I would be interested in peoples opinions of this subject, please post replies to moon net and not just direct to me as I am sure that others will be interested.

On 7-May-2001 G8MBI wrote:
According to results of my modelling experiments then 'phase' issues are over hype'd

having said that good or perfect, is better than error.

the first really noticable effect is a dip forming in the antennas normally 'smooth' nose pattern, this becomes visible on simulation plots at about 10 degrees of error. But you would never find it (at 144 anyway) in real world measurement.

2 times 17m2 bayed at dl6wu spacing =4492mm

                ---phase one antenna with respect to other degrees---

        ref     -5      -10     -15     -20     -25     -30
gain    17.6    17.59   17.56   17.52   17.46   17.38   17.29
F/B     19.2    19.2    19.2    19.2    19.2    19.2    19.2
1st lobe       -10.72   -10.33  -9.96   -9.56   -.05    -8.56

As I wrote last week below about 10 degrees it is insignificant.

these are peak gain, the dip forming in the centre will give a small 'hole' in this range of error, my notes do not show any measurement of the hole, I assume then, that at the time I thought it was not significant enough to write down, it tends to form but then flatten until you go very extreme.

I know for a fact that the most common construction cock up of 180 degree error is easily found as the hole is actually 'audiable' when the antenna is moved from side to side....(don't ask me how !!)

don't do it...but below 10 or 15 degrees of error, the world ain't gonna end as MANY forecast it will on this subject.

Your mileage may vary according to antenna used, segmentation, and modelling package.

On 7-May-2001 Mark  wrote:
In broadcast antenna arrays the spec used on most systems is +-5 Deg error. This is primarily for control of sidelobe response. It is tight enough to allow for real variations that occur when distribution cables are bent into position. The antenna pattern will not be significantly disturbed with errors less than 10 Deg, Aim for a very acheivable 5 deg and you have the confidence that the array will work properly. Note that if you are unsing foam filled hardline cables, different batches from the same manufacturer can have noticibly different velocity factors. Over long lengths it is possible to have 2 cables of similar mechanical length with a different no. of electrical wavelengths for each. Worst case you can have a cable exactly half wave out, by most phasing methods. Do your phasing at more than one frequency, and start at a low frequency to set the ball park length. and move to the operating frequency or above when you are sure you cannot make a halfwave error.

On 7-May-2001 G0RUZ wrote:
Hi Mark, Graham et all your advice echoes what John Denby G3TSA said. I forgot to point out that I had already started the checking process at 30Mhz and worked up to 144. The cable was all off the same roll and it all seems to work very well. You can get very close mechanically with the method I used. I am quite convinced that I am measuring things properly. So on 144 I reckon if you use cable off the same roll and cut the cable mechanically accurately you will have little to worry about.

On 7-May-2001 SM5BSZ wrote:
The far field of any antenna is completely defined by the field on a surface that surrounds the antenna. (Maxwells equations)

This means one can calculate the far field radiation pattern as if the field was generated by radiators on the surface excited proportional to the field on the surface.

For highly directive antennas like the ones we use for EME the field is small everywhere except in front of the antenna so the far field is completely defined by the field on a flat surface in front of the antenna because the field on the rest of a surface that would be required to contain the antenna in a closed volume will be so small that the contributions can be neglected.

Imagine a flat surface about 1 stacking distance away from the last director. Compare it to a flat surface in front of a parabolic dish.

The phase and amplitude should be constant in both cases. The far field 'does not know' if the antenna is a parabola or something else so start by considering a parabolic reflector:

There are rules of thumb saying the accuracy of the parabolic surface has to be better than +/- 0.1wl corresponding to a phase error of +/- 0.2wl = +/- 72 degrees!!!!! (most unfavourable case) There will be some loss of gain, I do not have any book with design rules for parabolas but I think the expected loss vs parabola accuracy is well known in this group.

In case the antenna behind the imaginary flat surface is a yagi array we do not have to make the phase better than we have to in the parabolic reflector case.

We have to worry about ALL contributions to phase errors!!!!

In order of significance (probably):

1) Boom mounting poistion. All feed points have to be in a plane. If the support structure sags when the antenna is elevated the phase will differ by the amount that the feed points deviate from the best fitted flat surface. (Look at the elevated antenna from the side and place youe eyes in the plane of the radiators. It is then easy to estimate the deviations from a flat surface if you also hold a thin tube in the plane a meter away from your eyes to get a straight line to compare to)

2) Antennas. A yagi antenna is a high Q resonator. The current in the radiator is not in phase with the drive voltage from the cable unless the impedance is resistive. Even if the impedance is forced to be 50 ohms resistive by some tunable matching device the outgoing wave may still differ in phase if the antennas are different.

Even if the antennas are mechanically identical so they give accurately the same phase when measured one by one, the phase of the outgoing wave may differ because of detuning due to improper mounting of the antennas.

a) Understacking. The field from the near neighbours may produce additional currents on the antennas that twist the phase of the total current (also changes the feed impedance). In a 4-stack all yagis see the same effect but in a larger array the effect differs for different antenna positions.

b) Booms or elements from other yagis at other frequency bands couple to the E-field of some yagis, lowering their resonance frequency while other yagis are unaffected.

3) Cables. Normally the phase shift from cables is accurately determined by the physical length. On 144MHz some serious mistake is required to loose gain by phase errors due to cable length errors but maybe(?) one has to be careful on 432MHz when using open balanced lines.

Do not worry too much about the cables!


(Note: I'm not showing any E-Mail address here in order to avoid them from being collected by SpamBots. You can possibly find the E-Mail addresses of the above OM at QRZ.COM.)

This discussion is still not closed. If you have any opinions or additional related information you would like to be published here, just send me an E-Mail

Read other Moon-Net discussions

 
Share: Twitter   Facebook   Home page Site map Radio Sherlock search engine Terms of service  Privacy  Cookies